Follow-up to Latin Squares

As for Randomized Complete Block Design, described in Follow-up RCBD Testing, the Latin Squares data analysis tool supports two follow-up tests: Contrasts and Tukey HSD.

Contrasts

Example 1:  As we see from Figure 1 of Latin Squares with Replication, there is a significant difference between the treatments in Example 1 of Latin Squares with Replication. Use contrasts to determine whether there is a significant difference between treatment C and the average of treatments A and B.

You can accomplish this analysis by choosing the Latin Squares data analysis tool and checking the Contrasts option on the dialog box, as shown in Figure 1 of Latin Squares Tools. After entering the contrast coefficients in range V3:V5 of Figure 1, we get the following analysis.

Latin squares contrasts

Figure 1 – Contrasts for Latin Square design

We see from cell AB10 that there is a significant difference between treatment C and the average of treatments A and B.

Cell U10 contains the formula =SQRT(P9*SUMSQ(V3:V5)/((O5+1)*(O6+1))), cell W10 contains the formula =O9 and cell X10 contains the formula =T.DIST.2T(ABS(V10),W10). Many of the other formulas in Figure 1 are similar to those in Figure 3 of RCBD Follow-up Testing.

Tukey’s HSD

Example 2: Use Tukey’s HSD to determine which pairs of treatments from Example 1 have significantly different yields.

You can accomplish this analysis by choosing the Latin Squares data analysis tool and checking the Tukey’s HSD option in the dialog box, as shown in Figure 1 of Latin Squares Tools, to obtain the output displayed in Figure 2.

Tukey Latin Squares

Figure 2 – Tukey’s HSD for Latin square design

Figure 2 shows that treatments A and C have significantly different yields, while other comparisons are not significant.

Links

↑ Latin squares design

Examples Workbook

Click here to download the Excel workbook with the examples described on this webpage.

References

Montgomery, D. C. (2012) Design and analysis of experiments. 8th ed. Wiley
https://faculty.ksu.edu.sa/sites/default/files/douglas_c._montgomery-design_and_analysis_of_experiments-wiley_2012_edition_8.pdf

Zhang, M. (2015) Latin Squares and Related Designs
https://www.stat.purdue.edu/~minzhang/514-Fall2015/lec%20notes_files/Lec7-latinsquare.pdf

Leave a Comment