Binomial and Normal Distributions Proof

Property A: The moment generating function for a random variable with distribution B(n, p) is

image3254

where q = 1 – p.

Proof: Using the definition of the binomial distribution and the definition of a moment generating function, we have

image3256

Observation: You can use the moment generating function to calculate the mean and variance (namely Property 1 of Binomial Distribution).

image3257

image3258

image3259

image3260

Property 1: If x is a random variable with distribution B(n, p), then for sufficiently large n, the distribution of the variable

image522

where
image523

Proof: By the linear transformation properties of the moment generating function (i.e Property 3 of General Properties of Distributions),

image3266

Taking the natural log of both sides, and then expanding the power series of e^{\theta/\sigma} we get

image3268

Since p + q = 1 we have

image3270

If n is made sufficiently large \sigma = \sqrt{npq} can be made large enough that for any fixed θ the absolute value of the sum above will be less than 1. Let

Thus for sufficiently large n, |t| < 1. The ln term in the previous expression is ln(1+t) where |t|<1, and so we may expand this term as follows:

This means that

By collecting terms in powers of θ/σ, we see that

Here, the ck terms don’t involve n, σ or θ. Since μ = np and σ2np(1 – p), the coefficient of the θ term is 0 and the coefficient of the θ2 term is 1. Thus

Since the coefficient of each term in the sum has form


Thus
image3287

and so
image3288

But note that by Property 3 of Normal Distribution the moment generating function for a random variable z with distribution N(0, 1) is

image3290

The result now follows by Corollary 1 of General Properties of Distributions.

References

Hoel, P. (1962) Introduction to mathematical statistics, 3rd Ed. John Wiley and Sons

Bass, R. F. et al. (2020) Normal approximation to the binomial
Chapter 9 of Upper level undergraduate probability with actuarial and financial applications
https://probability.oer.math.uconn.edu/wp-content/uploads/sites/2187/2018/01/prob3160ch9.pdf

10 thoughts on “Binomial and Normal Distributions Proof”

  1. Good day Charles,

    Is it possible there is a typo in the proof in the part just after :
    “By collecting terms in powers of θ/σ, we see that :” ?

    The exponent in the sum is (θ/σ)^3 where it seems to me it should be (θ/σ)^m.
    Which would be more coherent with the rest.

    Thank you,

    Reply
    • Hello Yoan,
      Yes, you are correct. The 3 should be an m. I have just corrected this on the webpage.
      Thank you very much for finding this error and improving the accuracy of the website.
      Charles

      Reply
    • Hello Alan,
      No, they should be different. Thank you for identifying this inconsistency in notation. I have now corrected this part of the proof.
      I appreciate your help in making the website clearer and easier to understand.
      Charles

      Reply
  2. At the part where you say “Here, the ck terms don’t involve n, σ or θ.” How does theta squared become divided by 2 and how does the sum change to include m in the exponents.

    Reply
    • Hello,
      I inadvertently left out the k! terms in the power series. In the second equation after the phrase “This means”, the p term should be divided by 1!, the p^2 term should be divided by 2! (this is the missing 2), the p^3 term should be divided by 3!, etc.
      Since I previously used k as the index in two different sums, I had to change one of them to a different index: I chose m for this index. I see that this is confusing.
      Thank you for your comment. I can see that I need to review the proof and correct the error and make things clearer.
      Charles

      Reply
  3. At the part where you say “Rearranging the terms, we have”, how are you going from the expression containing an infinite series with z terms, to another expression containing an infinite series with c terms? I really don’t see it.

    Reply

Leave a Comment